Why does my manager try to take over everything? (And how to handle it)

Have you ever worked on a project, felt completely on top of things, only to have your manager step in, grab the wheel, and start driving? It can be a frustrating and confusing experience. You might start feeling micro-managed and undervalued or even start to question your own competence.

Portrait of Dr Jana Paulech

By

· 5 min read

Watercolour illustration: a manager in a coral shirt leans over a woman’s desk and points at her screen while she looks up, frustrated.

Before you assume the worst about your manager’s intentions, it helps to step back and look at the bigger picture. In many cases, a manager taking over isn’t about a lack of trust in you—it’s often about their own adjustment period, personal strengths, or underlying anxieties.

Understanding the "why" behind this behavior is the first step toward addressing it rather than ending up in an endless loop of frustration and can even improve your relationship with your manager. Let’s look at two common reasons why managers struggle to step back, and how you can navigate these situations with empathy, clear communication, and healthy boundary setting.

1. Tenure: How long have they been a manager?

A manager’s tenure and current role context play a massive part in how they delegate and interact with their team. When a boss is constantly stepping in, their experience level might be the primary driver.

The new manager transition

Moving from an individual contributor to a management role is one of the hardest transitions in any career. As an individual contributor, success is measured by what you execute directly. As a manager, success is measured by what your team achieves. This requires a completely different mindset. A new manager may simply have trouble letting go of the hands-on work because doing the work feels comfortable, familiar, and controllable.

The need to prove themselves

If your manager is new to the organization, they are likely under immense pressure to demonstrate their efficacy to higher-ups. They want to show that they can deliver results quickly, which can sometimes translate into taking over tasks themselves rather than taking the time to guide others.

A new working relationship

If your manager is simply new to managing you, they are still learning your skills, work habits, and reliability. Until a baseline of trust and mutual understanding is established, they might default to taking over to ensure nothing slips through the cracks.

2. Strengths: Are they over-using the Executing domain?

Another lens through which to view your manager’s behavior is individual strengths. People who thrive in the Executing domain excel at getting things done, turning ideas into reality, and working tirelessly toward completion. Strengths like achiever, arranger, discipline, responsibility and restorative are great for getting things done, but when overused when managing others can lead to taking over.

Over-reliance on execution

When someone has strong executing drives, their natural instinct when faced with a goal or deadline is to roll up their sleeves and do it themselves. If they are used to leveraging these strengths to solve problems, they might over-use them—stepping into your projects without realizing they are encroaching on your responsibility.

Conflicting strengths

This can become particularly challenging if your own strengths lie in a different domain, such as Strategic Thinking, Influencing, or Relationship Building. If your approach involves planning, analyzing, or collaborating before diving into action, an execution-focused manager might interpret your deliberate process as hesitation or delay. To bridge the gap, they jump in to "help" in the only way they know how: by taking over execution.

How to handle it: Open acknowledgements and kind boundaries

Resolving this dynamic requires open acknowledgement of the situation paired with kind, constructive boundary setting. Your goal is not to confront or criticize, but to collaborate on a working style that gives your manager peace of mind while protecting your autonomy.

How you approach the conversation depends on the underlying context.

Scenario A: Working with a new manager

When dealing with a new manager or someone new to managing you, building their confidence in your ability to execute is key. You want to reassure them that the project is in safe hands while establishing a communication routine that keeps them informed without overloading either of you with constant check-ins.

What you can say

“I know you have a lot on your plate, and I want to give you the confidence that I have the ability to execute this project successfully. I understand how important it is to get it right and keep you updated, so how can I best keep you informed on progress and ask for support if I need it? I’d love to set up a process that gives you visibility without overburdening us with endless updates, so we both feel confident it’s all on track.”

This approach shows empathy for their workload, acknowledges the importance of the project, and invites them to co-design a communication schedule.

Scenario B: Navigating conflicting strengths

When the challenge stems from a mismatch in strengths, frame the conversation around leveraging what both of you bring to the table. Acknowledge their natural talent for execution while establishing clear boundaries around who owns the work.

What you can say

“I know one of your greatest strengths is in execution and getting things done efficiently, while my strengths focus more on strategic planning and relationship building. I can see how our different approaches might lead to a bit of overlap when I’m leading a project. I’d love to discuss how we can best leverage each other’s strengths while avoiding stepping on each other’s toes or duplicating effort. How about we brainstorm a process that lets me maintain primary execution responsibility while still drawing on your executing strengths whenever support is needed?”

By framing the issue around complementary strengths rather than faulty behavior, you create a safe space for collaboration without putting your manager on the defensive.

Moving forward

It’s easy to feel frustrated when a manager takes over your work, but viewing their behavior through the lens of tenure and natural strengths can transform friction into an opportunity for growth and effective relationship building.

By proactively initiating open, supportive conversations and setting gentle boundaries, you can build a working relationship built on mutual trust, clear ownership, and shared success.

Portrait of Dr Jana Paulech

Dr Jana Paulech

BSc(Hons), GradDip(Psyc), PhD · Co-author of StrengthsWire

Former principal consultant to some of Australia’s largest companies on strategy for connection and performance. Jana uses individual and organisational psychology to help teams understand and respect each other.

About StrengthsWireFollow Jana on LinkedIn